In 1867 The Gilbertville Congregation organized. They met in the “Gilbertville Hall” (currently the VFW) until 1872 when the membership had outgrown the Hall. The church was built using $20,000 left by George H. Gilbert and a matching grant of $20.000 from the George H. Gilbert Company. The company also donated the land. The foundations were begun in June 1872. The Church was completed and dedicated in September 1874. Seating capacity was about 350. It was described as “a perfect gem of architecture and the crowning ornament of the most beautiful manufacturing village in the Commonwealth.”
The architect was E. Boyden and Son of Worcester. Elbridge Boyden (1810–1898) designed many public buildings throughout the country, chiefly in New England. Area buildings he designed include Mechanics Hall in Worcester, The public library in Hubbardston, and the Congregational church in Brookfield.
The Tudor Gothic style church would be 88 feet long and 60 feet wide with a 127 foot tower. The church was built of Monson Granite. The master builder and contractor were from Providence RI. Interior illumination was by gas, before electrification. There are disconnected remnants of old gas illumination piping in the church attic and cellar.
Another endowment from the Gilbert Estate and matching funds from the Gilbert Company were used to purchase a Johnson and Son Organ in 1874. The organ has two manuals and 13 ranks and is labeled Opus 428. In 54 years the Johnson and Son Company built 860 organs. The company operated from 1844 through 1898. All Johnson organs were completely mechanical. In a tracker organ all the movements between the keys, pedals and valves are mechanical. This allows the organist to control the timing and force of the sound by touch.
A New Name
In 1879 the name of the church was changed to “Trinitarian Congregational Church.”
In 1883 Edward H. Gilbert presented the church with a McNeeley toned bell. The Meneely Foundries, a series of family-owned foundries, were established in 1826 and closed in 1952 Together the foundries produced about 65,000 bells.
In 1884 Lewis Gilbert had E. Boyden design a gothic style chapel to adjoin the church. In September 1884 the chapel was finished and the church was as we see it today. In 1911 work was done on the spire, which had been leaning for years. It was taken down above the bell level and rebuilt.
Interested in learning more? You can read our report to the Massachusetts Historical Commission on the history and condition of the building at this link.